Saturday, June 5, 2010

Lessons Learned from the Nazis

If you Google "lessons learned from the Nazis" you will see only 5 hits, and one of those is this blog. In all the billions of web pages out there on every topic possible, maybe this indicates that we have not learned a lot. (BTW "Lessons learned from Vietnam: 20,700 hits, "Lessons learned from the depression": 109,000. If you check this and I am wrong, please leave a comment, but remember that Google does change slightly with time)

What did we learn from the Nazis? Let's do it like a Letterman top ten list, start with the least important. I have actually 11.

11 - We need an international institution where the nations of the world can come together and discuss their differences, and solutions to war. That's why the UN was set up, and almost every country in the world participates.

10- Dictatorships tend to declare war with a lot less justification than true liberal democracies. But even having a democracy is no guarantee against being a warlike country. In fact some democracies are actually fake, where people are killed if they vote for the opposition. Or ballots are not fairly counted.

9- Every country in the world claims to be acting only in self defense, including the Nazis. Hitler frequently declared he was a man of peace. So words of peace alone are not a reliable indicator of peaceful intentions.

8- Arms buildups are not wrong all by themselves, but the size and intensity may be an indication of future trouble.

7- Nobody is allowed to use the legal defence "I was only following orders" when they are torturing and killing civilians.

6- Torturing people is wrong, that's why we have the Geneva convention.

5- Group punishments, and reprisals against innocent civilians for sabotage and terrorism are wrong.

4- Invading a foreign sovereign state is wrong. No excuses are permitted such as "They were mistreating their people" or "they attacked us first". The only acceptable way to invade a foreign country today would be with the full support of the rest of the international community, such as the UN, for example.

3- Hate propaganda against weak ethnic/religious groups is wrong, although this must be balanced against freedom of speech. At the very least, the ethnic/religious group should be given equal air time or print pages to respond to hate propaganda. And it is not only about the Jews, hate propaganda could be about any weak, minority group.

2- Gassing civilians to death based on religion/race/politics is wrong. Also wrong to do it based on intelligence. And not just gassing alone, any form of mass killing that you might ever invent in the future would still be wrong.

And finally, number one, numero uno, in all caps because it deserves it: NOBODY IS THE MASTER RACE


These are the lessons we should have learned from the Nazis. But in the sixty or so years since WW2 ended, we did not seem to really understand these lessons. We still can justify our own Nazi-like actions. And we are still reluctant to find out the truth about what is really going on right under our noses.

No matter how bloodthirsty and warlike we are, we always manage to compare ourselves to the Jews under Hitler, and compare our enemies to the Nazis. So it seems we have not really learned that much.

The most ironic example of ignoring the lessons from the Nazis is the Jews themselves, who are now occupying a country they invaded 40 years ago, and are still moving Jewish settlers into this occupied land, putting up barriers and military checkpoints up for Muslims, disallowing Muslims the freedom of housing, travel, or commerce. And of course they still compare themselves to the poor downtrodden Jews under Hitler all in the name of "Israel has the right to defend herself". Or maybe they did learn some lessons, but all the wrong ones.

3 comments:

  1. The primary lesson to be learned from the Nazi experience in Germany is that a civilized, cultured middle class may well accept a racist, authoritarian and militarily aggressive regime if their continued bourgeois existence is threatened.

    In the 1932 federal election the Nazi party became the largest party in the Reichstag, and Hitler was subsequently appointed chancellor in January 1933. It's critical to bear in mind that the Nazi government was voted into power in a democracy.

    After the economic collapse during WWI, the hyperinflation of the early 1920s (where most middle class Germans lost all their savings), the political instability of the 1920s Weimar Republic, the 'threat' of the growing Communist party, enough Germans decided that the Nazi alternative might be an answer and hence the 1932 election results.

    Hilter's 'agenda' was no secret. Mein Kampf was published in 1925, defining (albeit in turgid prose) his positions, and a quarter of a million copies had been sold by the time he became chancellor.

    Hitler's success with German voters may well have been influenced by Mussolini's (1922) Fascist regime in Italy. Which, at least, had (notoriously and apocryphally) 'made the trains run on time.'

    Voters in all democracies forget the German experience at their peril. The simplistic solutions of the far right, their emphasis on 'law and order,' their efforts to compromise freedoms in the name of 'security,' their cronyism with the military-industrial complex all have parallels in today's democracies.

    ReplyDelete
  2. How could so many be lead to perform such horrific acts by so few? Its Very sad to reflect upon the fragile nature of humanity. Are any of us just a stones throw away to follow in such a way. I only pray that the answer is no but history has shown other wise.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When you break it down, not that many people performed horrific acts. One guy takes a Jew to a train station. Another guy closes the boxcar door on a bunch of people. Another guy shoves people into the showers. Many of the really disgusting jobs were performed by Jews who were forced to load the dead bodies into incineration pits. The majority of Germans enabled this horror by denying, and make excuses, and not taking the trouble to find out the truth. That's where they are just about the same as anyone else.

    What we must do today is be vigilant of the warning signs, to prevent this from happening again.

    ReplyDelete